|




|
|

EMAIL THIS
PRINT THIS
Share

Jeff Davis
|
Jeff Davis is a retired radio-TV journalist living in Gainesville, GA. Active in
civic and political affairs, he is past president of the Georgia Jaycees and former campaign chairman of the Georgia
Republican party. He volunteers as chairman of the Georgia Heritage Council.
He is a collateral descendant of President Jefferson Davis and a member of SCV Camp 1404 in Gainesville and National
Chairman of Public Relations and Media for SCV.
|
Empires: Complexity and Collapse
Commentary by J. A. Davis, 3/09/2010
"When experience is not retained, as among savages, infancy is perpetual. Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it. In the
first stage of life the mind is frivolous and easily distracted; it misses progress by failing in consecutiveness and persistence. This is the
condition of children and barbarians." --George Santayana, The Life of Reason, Volume I, Reason in Common Sense, Chapter 12, (1906)
"Human history becomes more and more a race between education and catastrophe." --H.G. Wells
"We should not look back unless it is to derive useful lessons from past errors, and for the purpose of profiting by dearly bought experience."
--George Washington
We have long pointed to history as the ultimate lesson book and our belief that we ignore history's lessons at our great peril. By definition, history began
when we developed written language in order to write down events for the education of posterity. Advanced civilization was made possible by the accumulation
of knowledge and wisdom, by passing down the ideas in a more reliable and permanent way than oral traditions.
Let me stop here and offer a couple of acknowledgments. First, to my friend Jim Wesberry who sent me the Foreign Affairs article entitled,
Complexity and Collapse by Niall Ferguson
referenced
below. Secondly, to recognize the article came through the auspices of the Council on Foreign Relations which I have had occasion to observe and
participate with, often but not always, to my chagrin.
To read the full article requires a FREE registration on their Foreign Affairs website --- it is VERY worthwhile. We
noted a similar but condensed version was published Feb. 28th in the LA Times entitled
America, the fragile empire.
It is with that kind of open mind that I introduce our GHC readers to what I believe may be the best chronicle I have read on the rise and fall of empires
throughout history.
You should be warned that Ferguson's essay is long and may take more time than you have at the moment. If so, I urge you to set it aside until you can take the time
to read it, and even more, contemplate what it is telling you.
This one essay ties together the history of the chaos that has been associated with empires from the very earliest Mayans to the impending collapse of
the United States empire. It is thoughtfully done and played pretty straight from real history as opposed to what some have reconstructed and
called history. If nothing else, reading this article will explain why GHC's writers have expressed constant concern addressing empires,
empire building and the pending consequences.
We are at the edge of a slippery slope leading to a deep dark canyon. It is not out of the realm of reason to believe that our only hope may lie in returning
to the principles of our Founders and rebuking the two hundred or more years of usurpation, corruption, greed, lies and outright trickery in the
years that followed them--- including most assuredly, the present. The Founders repeatedly expressed the wisdom of non-interventionism, but perhaps most
concisely in Jefferson's 1801 inaugural address:
"...peace, commerce, and honest friendship with all nations, entangling alliances with none." --Thomas Jefferson, from First Inaugural Address, March 4, 1801
In Empire or Liberty?,
Steve Scroggins makes the case for reducing the size of our Empire and our military spending. He builds on the case presented by Patrick Buchanan in his
commentary entitled, Liquidating the Empire.
As Scroggins points out, the centralization of power (in D.C.) threatens our liberties on multiple fronts but none more obvious than excessive taxation that
violates our property rights and the very real risk of financial disaster posed by excessive spending and
public debt.
"We must return to our Founding roots and the Founding Principles.
Entangling alliances---sever them. Public debt---pay if off and use it sparingly. Government spending---multiple amputations are required to LIMIT spending
to Constitutionally authorized objects. We must drive back the socialist progressive centralizers as well as the neocon globalist centralizers to secure
our liberties and control of our government." --Steve Scroggins, from Empire or Liberty?, 2/26/10
One obvious point about the Constitution and complexity merits mention. The Founding Principles
and the original Constitution emphasize a LIMITED government.
The budget and fiscal structure of the U.S. government would be far, far simpler if our government's scope and spending were limited
to constitutionally authorized activities. Proper oversight for extremely complex systems becomes impossible once a certain threshold of scope and complexity is reached, for example,
the U.S. tax code and the U.S. federal budget. Most people cannot truly conceive
a trillion dollars,
much less a debt of $12.5 trillion and an unfunded entitlement
obligation of $108 trillion. If the Leviathan cannot be reduced to a manageable size, meaningful control and oversight is impossible, and our pretense at the
concept of "self government" is a farce.
Niall Ferguson's brilliant Complexity and Collapse essay
underscores the concerns we've expressed for a sudden economic collapse. Our current trajectory is NOT sustainable. Presented below are a few excerpts from
Ferguson's esssay. Ferguson's primary thrust is that historians paint the fall of various empires as a gradual and slow process. Ferguson contends that
the change is sudden, and the end of empires moves from perceived normalcy to crisis to desolation very rapidly.
"Great powers and empires are, I would suggest, complex systems... They operate somewhere between order and disorder -- on 'the edge of chaos'...
Such systems can appear to operate quite stably for some time; they seem to be in equilibrium but are, in fact, constantly adapting. But there comes a
moment when complex systems 'go critical.' A very small trigger can set off a 'phase transition' from a benign equilibrium to a crisis... "
--Niall Ferguson
"What is most striking about this history is the speed of the Roman Empire's collapse. In just five decades, the population of Rome itself fell by
three-quarters. Archaeological evidence from the late fifth century -- inferior housing, more primitive pottery, fewer coins, smaller cattle -- shows
that the benign influence of Rome diminished rapidly in the rest of western Europe. What Ward-Perkins calls "the end of civilization" came within
the span of a single generation."
---Niall Ferguson
"Other great empires have suffered comparably swift collapses. The Ming dynasty in China began in 1368, when the warlord Zhu Yuanzhang renamed himself
Emperor Hongwu, the word hongwu meaning 'vast military power.' For most of the next three centuries, Ming China was the world's most sophisticated
civilization by almost any measure. ...The transition from Confucian equipoise to anarchy took little more than a decade."
---Niall Ferguson
The most recent and familiar example of precipitous decline is, of course, the collapse of the Soviet Union. With the benefit of hindsight, historians
have traced all kinds of rot within the Soviet system back to the Brezhnev era and beyond. ...governments in what was then called the Third World, from
Vietnam to Nicaragua, had been tilting in the Soviets' favor for most of the previous 20 years. Yet less than five years after Gorbachev took power, the
Soviet imperium in central and Eastern Europe had fallen apart, followed by the Soviet Union itself in 1991. If ever an empire fell off a cliff -- rather
than gently declining -- it was the one founded by Lenin."
---Niall Ferguson
"If empires are complex systems that sooner or later succumb to sudden and catastrophic malfunctions, rather than cycling sedately from Arcadia to Apogee
to Armageddon, what are the implications for the United States today? First, debating the stages of decline may be a waste of time -- it is a precipitous
and unexpected fall that should most concern policymakers and citizens. Second, most imperial falls are associated with fiscal crises. All the above cases
were marked by sharp imbalances between revenues and expenditures, as well as difficulties with financing public debt. Alarm bells should therefore be
ringing very loudly, indeed, as the United States contemplates a deficit for 2009 of more than $1.4 trillion -- about 11.2 percent of GDP, the biggest
deficit in 60 years -- and another for 2010 that will not be much smaller. Public debt, meanwhile, is set to more than double in the coming decade, from
$5.8 trillion in 2008 to $14.3 trillion in 2019. Within the same timeframe, interest payments on that debt are forecast to leap from eight percent of
federal revenues to 17 percent."
---Niall Ferguson [emphasis added]
"For now, the world still expects the United States to muddle through, eventually confronting its problems when, as Churchill famously said, all the
alternatives have been exhausted. Through this lens, past alarms about the deficit seem overblown, and 2080 -- when the U.S. debt may reach staggering
proportions -- seems a long way off, leaving plenty of time to plug the fiscal hole. But one day, a seemingly random piece of bad news -- perhaps a
negative report by a rating agency -- will make the headlines during an otherwise quiet news cycle. Suddenly, it will be not just a few policy wonks
who worry about the sustainability of U.S. fiscal policy but also the public at large, not to mention investors abroad. It is this shift that is
crucial: a complex adaptive system is in big trouble when its component parts lose faith in its viability."
---Niall Ferguson [emphasis added]
"...empires behave like all complex adaptive systems. They function in apparent equilibrium for some unknowable period. And then, quite abruptly, they
collapse. To return to the terminology of Thomas Cole, the painter of The Course of Empire, the shift from consummation to destruction and then to
desolation is not cyclical. It is sudden."
---Niall Ferguson
|
Ferguson uses the metaphor of a train wreck as depicted in a once popular poster showing a runaway train crashed through a rail station. Scroggins,
in Vertical Debt Limit uses
the metaphor of a mountain climber sliding rapidly down a steep slope toward a cliff and certain death. Both metaphors involve a build up of
momentum that is difficult to stop as the catastrophic end nears. Another metaphor from antiquity was used by the rock band Kansas, that of a ship
sailing off the edge of the earth (as shown on the album art
for their 1977 album entitled "Point of Know Return"). Whichever metaphor suits your taste, the
end will be sudden and the result catastrophic.

They say the sea turns so dark that
You know it's time, you see the sign
They say the point demons guard it
An ocean grave, for all the brave,
Was it you that said, "How long, how long,
How long to the point of know return?"
from --Point of Know Return, Kansas, 1977
Our populace must be informed, better prepared to deal with what is ahead. The real patriots will trade the toys and trinkets of the great Roman circus for
a chance to survive in liberty. The warning signs are upon us and as Ferguson suggests, alarm bells should be "ringing very loudly." History shows that
most empires don't decline in a slow process; people choose to ignore warning signs, they falsely believe in equilibrium and the collapse takes most
people by surprise. Once the final crisis begins, the desolation and chaos to follow unfolds in a decade or less. The time to return to the Founding
Principles and fiscal sanity is now, before we reach the point of no return.
Jeff Davis is a retired radio-TV journalist living in Gainesville, GA. Active in
civic and political affairs, he is past president of the Georgia Jaycees and former campaign chairman of the Georgia
Republican party. He volunteers as chairman of the Georgia Heritage Council.
He is a collateral descendant of President Jefferson Davis and a member of SCV Camp 1404 in Gainesville and National
Chairman of Public Relations and Media for SCV.
Like this? SIGN UP now
for weekly email updates in your inbox !!
Contribute now to help us maintain this website and carry on our mission!
Related Links
Vertical Debt Limit - Steve Scroggins 3/02/10
Worse Than We're Told; Next Election Cycle May Be Too Late - Commentary by J.A. Davis 2/27/10
Empire or Liberty? - Steve Scroggins 2/26/10
What is States' Rights? - Part 2 - Mike Crane 2/24/10
Washington's Integrity - Steve Scroggins 2/22/10
Voting Rights, Responsibilities (Part 2) - Steve Scroggins 2/19/10
Defending Truth is Doing One's Duty - J.A. Davis 1/31/10
A Troubled New Year - J.A. Davis 12/31/09
A Fine Mess - J.A. Davis 12/11/09
Liberty Lost Part 9 - Rebirth of the Republic - J.A. Davis
SPLC Reputation as Frauds and Conmen Grows - J.A. Davis & Steve Scroggins
Perils of Democracy, Part 5 - J.A. Davis & Steve Scroggins
Black History Month and 'Civil War Memory' - Bill Vallante 2/01/10
Remembering Robert E. Lee's 203rd Birthday - Calvin E. Johnson, Jr. 1/05/10
The Death of Robert E. Lee - Calvin E. Johnson, Jr. 10/08/09
The John B. Gordon Story - Calvin E. Johnson, Jr. 1/30/10
Climate Fraud Shows Government is the Problem - Frank Gillispie, 12/03/09
Climategate is a symptom, not the disease - Jim Dean, 12/2/09
The American Ideal of 1776: The Twelve Basic American Principles - Hamilton Abert Long
Liberty Lost - Part 8 - J.A. Davis
EMAIL THIS
PRINT THIS
Share
|
Copyright © 2003-2012, GeorgiaHeritageCouncil.org
Georgia Heritage Council | 2121 Hollywood RD
Atlanta, GA 30318 Email:
|



|